From the Abstract to the Concrete - Teaching Algorithms and Concepts with SVG Interactive Tools

Keywords: algorithm visualization, interactive graphics, web design

Catherine R. Emond, BSc
University of Victoria
Victoria
British Columbia
Canada
cemond@uvic.ca

Biography

Catherine Emond has just completed her BSc in Computer Science at the University of Victoria. This has given her the skills needed to learn how to create the SVG interactive algorithm visualizations described in this paper. The motivation to animate these visualizations derives from her background in modern dance/choreography, automotive mechanics and industrial automation.

Ulrike Stege, Ph.D
University of Victoria
Victoria
British Columbia
Canada
stege@cs.uvic.ca

Biography

Ulrike Stege received her doctoral degree in Computer Science (2000) from ETH Zurich. She is now an Assistant Professor at the Department of Computer Science of the University of Victoria. Her current research interests include Computational Biology, Parameterized Complexity, the Design of Heuristics, Graph Theory, and Cognitive Psychology.

Eric Manning, Ph.D
University of Victoria
Victoria
British Columbia
Canada
Eric.Manning@engr.uvic.ca

Biography

Eric Manning received a Ph.D in Electrical Engineering (1965) from the University of Illinois. He was then Assistant Professor and Ford Postdoctoral Fellow at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, and a Member of Technical Staff at the Bell Telephone Laboratories, Inc. He then joined the University of Waterloo and then the University of Victoria where he was Dean of Engineering, and Professor of Electrical & Computer Engineering and Computer Science. Since 2001 he has been the Nortel Networks / New Media Innovation Centre Professor of Network Performance at the University of Victoria, and NewMIC (New Media Innovation Centre) Scientist in Network Performance. He has conducted research in the areas of fault diagnosis in digital systems, computer networks, distributed processing, distributed simulation, and multimedia Quality of Service, and has written over 100 articles on these topics. He is a Fellow of the IEEE (Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers) and is cited in Who's Who in America and in Who's Who in Canada. He is currently studying redesign of the Internet to carry multimedia.


Abstract


The understanding of algorithms is a crucial aspect of most computer science courses. It is also a crucial aspect of interdisciplinary research involving computer science. Understanding the design and analysis of algorithms and data structures involves the ability to analyze algorithms, and to understand their underlying concepts. One aid to support the teaching of algorithms is their animation and visualization. In this paper we describe visualization tools that we developed as teaching aids for two different computer -science courses: a third-year course in Computer Architecture and a second year course in Algorithms and Data Structures. Approaches to setting up the animation sequences are discussed, including usability issues. Examples of our animations are presented and methods of construction are discussed. The animation and visualization tools which we created support not only properties like web-accessibility and interactivity, but also allow the students to make predictions and receive feedback.


Table of Contents


Introduction
Usability Design Goals
Visualization Tools
CSc 350: Computer Architecture - Examples
     MIPS Addressing Mode
     State Machine versus Microsteps
     Network Pipeline
     Simple Machine
     Page Algorithm
     Data Dependencies
     Direct Mapped Cache
CSc 225: Algorithms and Data Structures - Examples
     Heap Data Structure
     Growth Rate Graphs
     Binary Search Pseudocode
Conclusion
Footnotes
Bibliography

Introduction

The understanding of algorithms is a crucial aspect of most computer science courses, as well as of interdisciplinary research involving computer scientists and researchers in areas as biology, geography, and economics. Crucial issues for understanding the design and analysis of algorithms are the ability to analyze algorithms, and to understand their underlying and data structures and concepts. In this article we present different SVG (Scalable Vector Graphics) tools that are designed to (1) aid the teaching of algorithms in course of a lecture and (2) support and motivate student learning in such a course in an interactive way.

AV (Algorithm visualization) , is a form of software visualization [Pri93] , and is concerned with illustrating computer algorithms in terms of their high-level operations, usually for the purpose of enhancing computer science students' understanding of the algorithms' procedural behaviour [Hun02] . It can help create a concrete visual image of an algorithm and of its underlying concepts, and it can accommodate different learning styles [Wil02] . AV is most effective when it encourages students to engage actively in their own learning, as in programming and homework exercises (see e.g., [Hun02] , [Nap00] ). In particular, "the presence of algorithm animations seems to make a challenging algorithm more accessible and less intimidating, thus leading to enhanced student interaction with the materials and facilitating learning." [Keh99] . Also, AV can have increased pedagogical value when it is used in coordination with other learning materials, or accompanies other material which explains how the animation simulates an algorithm's operations.

The movie Sorting Out Sorting by R.M. Baecker is the first major example of AV [Bae81] , [Bae98] . Examples for further algorithm animations are BALSA (Brown ALgorithm Simulator and Animator) [Bro84] , [Bro88] , TANGO (Transition-based Animation GeneratiOn) [Sta92] , XTANGO [Sta92] , POLKA [POLKA] , Samba [SAMBA] , JSamba [JSAMB] , Zeus [Bro91] , Leonardo [Cre97] , CATAI [CATAI] , and Mocha [Bak95] . With the usability of the World Wide Web, the use of algorithm animation systems is no longer confined to traditional classrooms or laboratory teaching, but can be easily extended to interactive use outside lab and class room as well as to distance education. Current web-accessible AV technologies are usually JAVA based, and are often based on a client-server model (e.g., HalVis [Han99] , JHAVE [Nap00] , and JSamba [JSAMB] ). In [You00] an overview of existing animation and visualization tools is given and the use of algorithm animation in education is investigated and its effectiveness is analyzed.

In this article we describe visualization tools that we developed as teaching aids for two different computer-science courses at the University of Victoria: a third-year course in Computer Architecture (CSc 350), and a second year course in Algorithms and Data Structures (CSc 225). Approaches to setting up the animation sequences are discussed, including usability issues. Examples of our animations are presented and methods of construction are discussed. The animation and visualisation tools we created not only support properties like web-accessibility and interactivity, but also allow the students to make predictions (e.g., during the process of an algorithm) and receive feedback.

Usability Design Goals

The difficulty encountered by students trying to conceptually translate static textbook diagrams into the dynamic processes which the diagrams represented was the motivation for creating the visualization tools discussed in this paper. Our goal was to create AV’s that would supplement textbooks and class notes [1] . The visualizations were to be (1) embedded in or linked to Microsoft PowerPoint slides for class lectures, and (2) embedded in HTML pages for Web viewing.

The visualization tools discussed in this paper are created as animations that focus on specific micro-level algorithmic and conceptual operations. These operations are referenced in the course text and slides [1] and then supplemented and motivated by the AV's . The textbook and slides in conjunction with the visualizations effectively create a multimedia presentation of algorithms and concepts, which can always be available to the students via the textbook and the Web, and can be used for reading assignments and study aids.

Our design goal was to provide the student with the ability to view the visualization with at least one type of animation. Most of the AV's allow the sequencing of discrete snapshots of the algorithm or concept process, and a few also provide smoothly running animation. In the last three AV's created, Heap Data Structure , Growth Rate Graphs , and Binary Search Pseudocode , the students are first required to successfully answer a series of predictive questions or enter the data correctly before they are allowed to run the animation. This helps prevent the student from running the animation without understanding the algorithmic and conceptual operations presented in the animation.

In the design of the visualizations, three different types of design heuristics influenced us:

  1. Website design [Pre02] ,
  2. GUI (Graphic User Interface) usability design [Pre02] , and
  3. Algorithm visualization design [You00] .

The heuristics from these categories most helpful to our AV design were feedback, error recognition, animation control, help documentation, and accessibility.

Feedback to the student of the AV's system status is very important since the students can not run the more advanced visualization animations before they have correctly input the data set or completed answering the predictive question set. Feedback and error recognition is provided through colour and text change, cursor style change, pop–up text and pop-up alert windows.

Various methods can be used to control the animations:

  1. Mouse clicking on an object either changes the visibility property or stroke or fill colours of the targeted object and the next object(s) required in the algorithm animation sequence.
  2. HTML (HyperText Markup Language) or SVG buttons [5] allow animation, step-by-step incrementation, or resetting of the animation.
  3. The browser refresh button refreshes and resets the animation to the first image of the animation sequence.

Although the AV's do not have a reverse control for the discrete animation sequences, the sequences are short enough that a student can quickly step through the discrete sequences a second time and stop at the desired frame [3] .

The first seven AV's were primarily designed for in-class presentation, so no help documentation was initially provided, since the instructor was taught to use the visualization. However, when the AV's were embedded in HTML pages for Web accessibility, written help documentation was either inserted in the HTML page, or a link to a separate help page was added. This allowed the students to use the visualizations without prior in-class instruciton.

Visualization Tools

The AV 's are presented in the chronological order they were developed in over the last year. They were developed using JavaScript, HTML, SVG, and the Adobe Illustrator , Adobe GoLive , Macromedia Dreamweaver,TextPad, and Microsoft Internet Explorer 6 applications [2] .

The first seven visualizations CSc 350: Computer Architecture - Examples were created for the University of Victoria CSc 350 course Computer Architecture [1] . The AV's were primarily created for in-class PowerPoint presentations, and secondarily for website access. The SVG cleanly replicated diagrams of the course textbook or diagrams created by the course instructor. These seven AV's were created as sets of image layers [3] that were manipulated by the user to incrementally step through the images, which allowed one layer to be visible at a time. This was useful in class presentations where the professor could control the sequencing speed of the images according to class needs.

The last three AV visualizations were created for the University of Victoria CSc 225 course Algorithms and Data Structures [1] , and more closely follow the recommendations and insights of hypermedia/multimedia AV system research [Nap00] , [Han99/2] , which recommends encouraging both student interactivity and critical thinking through the use of predictive analysis. These last three AV 's, Heap Data Structure , Growth Rate Graphs and Binary Search Pseudocode , which have been primarily designed for web accessibility, require the students to input the data or to predict the order of the data sequence before they are allowed to run the animation. The animation of the algorithm is the reward for learning the specific operational details of the algorithm, with immediate feedback provided to the students as to whether their predictive answers were correct or not. In the last example, the students can view the correct answer after they have attempted to arrange the data into the correct sequence.

Unlike the first group of AV's that used hard coded data parameters that could not be modified by the student, the Heap Data Structure and Growth Rate Graphs visualizations do not rely on hard coded parameters but allow the student to input new data through HTML forms to modify the presentation. The Binary Search Pseudocode visualization uses hard coded data parameters but allows student mouse events to reposition SVG objects so that the student can rearrange the data into the correct order. These most recently developed AV's encourage more complex interactivity than the earlier AV through the addition of animation controls, data alteration, and predictive questions. The articulation milestones created by the predictive questions encourage critical thinking and active participation in the visualizations.

CSc 350: Computer Architecture - Examples

NOTE: Clicking on the link below each SVG figure will provide a full-screen, interactive version of the depicted image.

MIPS Addressing Mode

The "MIPS Addressing Mode" graphic set consists of a simple layering of sequential images. Only the first image in sequence is initially visible. A single JavaScript method allows one SVG object when clicked to become invisible and the next object [3] in the sequence to become visible. Objects are called by id. Below in Figure 1 is shown the first graphic of the set of four. Click on the image to sequence through the MIPs addressing process.

RFormat2.svg

Figure 1: R-Format Address Mode [4]

The full interactive version is available here: RFormat.html

Note the hand cursor. These are created by wrapping the <g> grouping elements with link <a></a> elements so that the browser was "fooled" into believing these were links. Although the documentation at http://www.w3.org/TR/SVG/interact.html#CursorProperty indicates that the cursor property could be modified in SVG , I was not successful implementing this method.

State Machine versus Microsteps

In this graphic, all the layers are visible. When a text object is clicked, the mouse event changes the colour property of another object. The elements are grouped so that only the text is the link, not the box or circle surrounding the text. In Figure 2 below, click on the Microstep stepnames to highlight the corresponding Finite State Machine nodes, or click on the node text to highlight the corresponding Microstep.

StateMicroComboLayersd.svg

Figure 2: Microsteps/Finite State Machine: A comparison of MIPS instruction classes [4]

The full interactive version is available here: StateMachine.html

This AV connects the two concepts of State Machine and Microsteps through comparison. These diagrams were adapted from the course textbook, which had the diagrams on separate pages. Comparing the two system diagrams was difficult yet important for understanding the course material. The diagrams are crowded when viewed on a computer monitor, but when supplemented with the textbook allows the student to quickly understand the connection between the two systems.

Network Pipeline

Adobe JavaScript example code [Adobe] was used to help create this first attempt at SVG animation. Most of the "animation" occurs by manipulating the layer sequence in the graphic, which requires considerable planning when one is organizing the graphic layers in Illustrator 10. When saving files as SVG in Illustrator 10, the sequence of layers are inverted from the order created in the Illustrator layer palette. SVG uses "painter’s algorithm" for rendering layers, in that the top-most object on the page is rendered first, which also means it has the lowest z-order or stacking order.

netwrkpipeline.svg

Figure 3: Network Pipelining

The full interactive version is available here: netwrkpipeline.html

The intricate layer management of this graphic show above in Figure 3 , is again controlled by mouse click events. Each colour change is created by object visibility property changes. Each object is a collection of xlink:hrefs attributes to predefined objects. This allows for the simultaneous animation of both network diagrams.

Simple Machine

Figure 4 below is another example of layer management. On mouse click events the SVG object fill and stroke properties change. Since more than one microstep can share the same bus path, the code has to check whether other microsteps are active before changing bus path colours. A problem that arises from this type of image management is that the code becomes very customized and is not easily recycled.

SimpleMachine.svg

Figure 4: Control in Action: Simple Machine [4]

The full interactive version is available here: SimpleMachine.html

Page Algorithm

Mouse click events are again utilized in Figure 5 below to allow an incremental step-through of the algorithm. When a column is clicked, the column data is rendered visible. The code does not control the columns’ visibility sequence, but since this diagram was created for in-class demonstration, it is assumed the instructor will control the sequence. The reset button renders all the column data visibility properties to "none" by calling a modified version of the Adobe JavaScript code [Adobe] used in Network Pipeline

pageAlgorithms.svg

Figure 5: Comparison of Page Replacement Algorithms [4]

The full interactive version is available here: Page.html

Data Dependencies

Figure 6 is an example of simple image management where mouse click events cause the SVG objects’ visibility properties to be modified. Again, the graphic was created for in-class demonstration, so the sequence of events is not controlled by the code but by a single knowledgeable user (the instructor). Therefore, the instructor must mediate the interaction of the class and the AV .

DataDependencies.svg

Figure 6: Data Dependencies in Program Execution Order [4]

The full interactive version is available here: datadep.html

Direct Mapped Cache

The algorithm is sequenced in Figure 7 by creating a new text node and replacing the current text with new text. This is the first example which we created that utilized parameter input to create the next frame in the animation sequence. The parameters are hard coded, which does not allow for student modification of the data. Basic help documentation is provided for the student, which allows this AV to be used without instructor mediation.

cache.svg

Figure 7: Direct Mapped Cache

The full interactive version is available here: cache.html

CSc 225: Algorithms and Data Structures - Examples

The last three AV's have links to instruction help pages, allowing the student to work through the animation exercises without prior teacher explanation. The SVG are embedded in HTML files since data input is achieved with HTML forms. Because of this embedding in HTML , these visualizations can be viewed at the respective URL's (Uniform Resource Locator) provided. We recommend using Internet Explorer Version 6+ to view them.

Heap Data Structure

http://www.cs.uvic.ca/~cemond/AlgorithmAnimation/testForm010803a.htm

This is the first AV that allows the student to input different data sets. The SVG diagram and an HTML form are placed in a HTML table. Data is entered in the form and the values used to create text nodes that replace the empty text nodes in the SVG diagram heap tree. The AV contains both SVG and HTML buttons [5] , with the HTML form button controlling student data input and help instruction access, and the SVG buttons controlling the heap data structure.

Growth Rate Graphs

http://www.cs.uvic.ca/~cemond/AlgorithmAnimation/growthrate/graphform021303_1.htm

The graphic setup is similar to Heap Data Structure , but the student data input is restricted to drop-down menu choices to ensure data consistency for data checking. The colour and text change to inform the student of correct data predictions. When the growth rate function order has been correctly chosen, SVG buttons appear for both incremental stepping and smooth animation through the function sequence. Note: once one of the SVG buttons is chosen, the other button is rendered invisible to prevent mouse event conflicts.

Binary Search Pseudocode

http://www.cs.uvic.ca/~cemond/AlgorithmAnimation/frameset06/pseudoFrameset.htm

The AV window is split into 3 HTML frames:

  1. The top frame holds a .gif title,
  2. The center frame holds pseudocode rendered in SVG , and
  3. The bottom frame holds control buttons rendered in SVG .

The frameset is used to preserve the measurement of the center frame so that the window workspace is always large enough to rearrange the pseudocode fragments, which are rendered in SVG within the center frame document. The inspiration for this exercise are the refrigerator magnets one can arrange into various prose and poetry. Since SVG does not yet support z-order property manipulation [z-Ord] , the code fragments are not dragged to a new position but instead rendered invisible when initially clicked upon and then rendered visible when the student clicks on the new desired position. This method of object position change prevents the objects from "catching" each other if they are dragged across each other when visible. The JavaScript code example written by Antoine Quint (http://www.xml.com/pub/a/2002/02/27/drag.html) was used as the "seed" code for the AV .

Calling objects and methods across frames requires "bubbling" up the objects and methods from the SVG document where they originate to the parent HTML document, and then to the frameset HTML document, where the other HTML frames can access them.

All buttons in this visualization are created in SVG , which means the colours of the buttons are not restricted to the default HTML form button colours, hence the lime green.

Conclusion

In this article we presented examples of visualization tools to support the teaching of algorithms that we can separate in two categories: In-class aids (MIPS addressing mode, State Machine versus Microsteps, Network Pipeline, Simple Machine, Page Algorithm, Data Dependencies, Direct Map Cache) that support the instructor and interactive student learning aids (Heap Data Structure, Growth Rate Graphs, Binary Search Pseudocode). Evaluation of the three latter tools is still in progress and will be conducted in the next Spring term (January-April 2004).

Footnotes

  1. CSc 225: Algorithms and Data Structures

    CSc 350: Computer Architecture

  2. Applications used in AV development:

    1. Adobe GoLive www.adobe.com/products/golive/main.html
    2. Adobe Illustrator www.adobe.com/products/illustrator/main.html
    3. Macromedia Dreamweaver www.macromedia.com/software/dreamweaver/
    4. Microsoft Internet Explorer 6 www.microsoft.com/windows/ie/default.asp
    5. TextPad www.textpad.com/

  3. In the AV example descriptions the terms layer and frame are used interchangeably. Adobe illustrator drawings are composed of objects or groups of objects that are positioned on layers. When the drawings are saved as SVG files, each layer becomes an SVG object that can be used as an animation frame, by sequencing object property modifications.

  4. These graphics that were used as basis for the SVG are © 1998 Morgan Kaufmann Publishers/Elsevier Science (USA). Reprinted with permission from Computer Organization and Design: The Hardware/Software Interface 2E.

  5. Even though SVG does not have a designated button tag like HTML , we will refer to the SVG objects in the AV 's that look like buttons as "buttons".

Bibliography

[Adobe]
Adobe SVG Zone http://www.adobe.com/svg/demos/samples.html
[Bae81]
Baecker, R.M. (1981): With the assistance of Dave Sherman, Sorting out Sorting, 30 minute colour sound film, Dynamic Graphics Project, University of Toronto, 1981. (Excerpted and 'reprinted' in SIGGRAPH Video Review 7, 1983.) (Distributed by Morgan Kaufmann, Publishers.)
[Bae98]
Baecker, R. (1998): Sorting out sorting: A case study of software visualization for teaching computer science. In: Software Visualization: Programming as a Multimedia Experience (M. Brown, J. Domingue, B. Price, and J. Stasko, eds.) The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, pp. 369-381.
[Bak95]
Baker, J.E., Cruz, I.F., Liotta, G., and Tamassia, R. (1995, December): A New Model for Algorithm Animation Over the WWW ACM Computing Surveys. Vol. 27 No.4. See also http://loki.cs.brown.edu:8080/pages/ (2003.05.28).
[Bro88]
Brown,(1988): Exploring Algorithms Using Balsa-II, IEEE Computer 21, pp. 14-36.
[Bro91]
Brown M.H. (1991): Zeus: A System for Algorithm Animation and Multi-View Editing, Proceedings of IEEE Workshop on Visual Languages, New York, pp. 4-9.
[Bro84]
Brown, M.H., Sedgewick R. (1984, July): A System for Algorithm Animation, Computer Graphics, pp.177-186.
[Byr96]
Byrne, M. D, Catrambone, Richard and Stasko, John T.(1996, August): Do Algorithm Animations Aid Learning?, Graphics, Visualization, and Usability Center, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA, Technical Report GIT-GVU-96-18.
[CATAI]
CATAI, http://www.dia.unisa.it/cattaneo.dir/CATAI/Spark.html (2003.05.28).
[Cre97]
Crescenzi, P., Demetrescu, C., Finocchi, I., Petreschi, R. (1997): Leonardo: a software visualization system, in Proceedings WAE'97, pp. 146-155.
[Georg]
Georgia Institute of Technology, web page on algorithm animation, http://www.cc.gatech.edu/gvu/softviz/algoanim/algoanim.html (2003.05.28).
[Han99]
Hansen, S.R., Narayanan, N.H., Schrimpsher D. (1999): Helping Learners Visualize and Comprehend Algorithms, Interactive Multimedia Electronic Journal of Computer-Enhanced Learning.
[Han99/2]
Hansen S., Schrimpsher D., Narayanan N. H. (1999): From algorithm animations to animation-embedded hypermedia visualizations, Proceedings of the World Conference on Educational Multimedia, Hypermedia & Telecommunications (ED-MEDIA'99), Association for the Advancement of Computing in Education.
[Hun02]
Hundhausen C., Douglas S., Stasko J. (2002, June): A Meta-Study of Algorithm Visualization Effectiveness, Journal of Visual Languages and Computing, Vol. 13, No. 3, pp. 259-290.
[JAWAA]
JAWAA and JELLRAP, http://www.cs.duke.edu/~rodger/tools (2003.05.28)
[JSAMB]
JSAMBA, algorithm animation system, Georgia Institute of Technology, http://www.cc.gatech.edu/gvu/softviz/algoanim/samba.html (2003.05.28).
[Jst90]
Jstasko, T. (1990, September): Tango: A Framework and System for Algorithm Animation, IEEE Computer 23, pp. 27-39.
[Keh99]
Kehoe C., Stasko J., Taylor A. (1999, March): Rethinking the Evaluation of Algorithm Animations as Learning Aids: An Observational Study, Graphics, Visualization, and Usability Center, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA, Technical Report GIT-GVU-99-10.
[Law94]
Lawrence, A.W. (1994): Empirically Evaluating the Use of Animation to Teach Algorithms, Technical Report GIT-GVU-94-07.
[Nap00]
Naps T. L., Norton L. L., Eagan J. R. (2000, March): JHAVÉ - An Environment to Actively Engage studentsin Web-based Algorithm Visualizations, in Proceedings of the SIGCSE Session, ACM Meetings,Austin, Texas.
[Neu00]
Neumann A., Winter A. (2000): Vector-based Web Cartography: Enabler SVG, http://www.carto.net/papers/svg/index_e.html,2000 (2003.28.05).
[Plumb]
Plumb Design, Visual Thesaurus. http://www.visualthesaurus.com/index.jsp (2003.05.28)
[POLKA]
POLKA, http://www.cc.gatech.edu/gvu/softviz/parviz/polka.html (2003.05.28).
[Pre02]
Preece, J., Rogers, Y., Sharp, H. (2002): Interaction design: beyond human-computer interaction,John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
[Pri93]
Price B. A., Baecker R. M., Small I. S. (1993): A principled taxonomy of software visualization. Journal of Visual Languages and Computing 4, 211-266.
[SAMBA]
Samba, http://www.cc.gatech.edu/gvu/softviz/algoanim/samba.html (2003.05.28).
[Sta92]
Stasko, J. (1992, Spring): Animating algorithms with XTANGO, SIGACT News 23, pp.67-71.
[Sta92/2]
Stasko J.T., Wehrli, J.F. (1992, September): Three-Dimensional Computation VisualizationGraphics, Visualization, and Usability Center, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA, Technical Report GIT-GVU-92-20.
[Sta93]
Stasko J., Bradre, A., Lewis, C. (1993, April): Do Algorithm Animations Assist Learning? An Empirical Study and Analysis, ACM INTERCHI, pp.61-66.
[Sta96]
Stasko, J.T. (1996,August): Using student-Built Algorithm Animations as Learning Aids, Graphics, Visualization, and Usability Center, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA, Technical Report GIT-GVU-96-19.
[Sta97]
Stasko, J.T. (1997): Using student-Built Algorithm Animations as Learning Aids, ACM SIGCSE, pp.25-29.
[Wil02]
Williams, F. M. (2002, July): Diversity, Thinking Styles, and Infographics, Paper presented at the ICWES12 Conference, Ottawa, Canada.
[You00]
Young, M.K.A. (2000): On-line Animation for a Programming Language Course, Honours thesis, School of Computer Science and Software Engineering, Monash University.
[z-Ord]
Scalable Vector Graphics (SVG) 1.2, W3C Working Draft 29 April 2003 www.w3.org/TR/SVG12/#rax-zorder

XHTML rendition created by gcapaper Web Publisher v2.0, © 2001-3 Schema Software Inc.